The Courage to Own a Mistake — Three Steps to a Real Apology
A forced "sorry" doesn't reach either your child or the other person. Here are three steps to an apology that comes from the heart.
When your child breaks a younger sibling’s toy, tosses out a quick “sorry,” and walks off, it’s hard not to think, “That’s it?” But often the person who made them say that short “sorry” was the parent. Forcing a child to say the words of an apology and a child finding the courage to admit a mistake on their own are completely different things.
Why it matters
According to research featured by UC Berkeley’s Greater Good Science Center, developmental psychologist Craig E. Smith and colleagues found that forced apologies actually fail to repair relationships between children. Children can tell the difference between a sincere apology and one that’s just said for form’s sake, and a forced apology doesn’t earn much trust from the child receiving it either. A 2012 study by psychologist Andrew Howell and colleagues, described in the same article, explains that effective apologies share several common elements: acknowledging specifically what you did wrong, accepting responsibility for it, expressing sincere regret, and adding an action to make things right. Making Caring Common at the Harvard Graduate School of Education also advises that rather than scolding the mistake itself, it matters for parents to help the child think through what they can learn from it.
Three steps to a real apology
- Step 1, say specifically what you did wrong: Instead of stopping at “sorry,” have your child name exactly what they did, like “for knocking down your block tower.”
- Step 2, think about how the other person feels: Have them add words that first consider what the other person must have felt, like “I think I know how upset you must have been.”
- Step 3, add a way to make it right: Don’t let it end with words — together, decide on an action to actually undo or make up for it, like “I’ll help you build it again.”
It’s okay if your child doesn’t do all three steps perfectly at once. Until they can remember the order on their own, it’s enough for you to stay nearby and guide with questions rather than pressure.
Try saying: “Before you say sorry, can you tell me what you did wrong?”
Try saying: “How do you think your little brother (sister) felt then? Let’s add something that shows you understand that feeling.”
Try saying: “Instead of stopping at words, is there a way to fix it right now?”
FAQ
What should I do if my child keeps refusing to apologize? Don’t try to drag it out of them on the spot. Give it time, and once feelings have settled, calmly go back over what they did wrong — that leads to a more sincere apology.
Isn’t it better to make them say “sorry,” even just as a formality? If saying it for form’s sake becomes a habit, your child may come to see an apology not as expressing what they truly feel, but as a procedure for getting past the moment. Practicing the three steps, even briefly, sticks longer.
Try this today
- Next time your child makes a mistake, have them first say specifically what they did wrong instead of just “sorry”
- Have them add one sentence to the apology that considers the other person’s feelings
- After the apology, find a small action with your child that can undo or make up for it
Sources
Last reviewed July 17, 2026
- Greater Good Science Center (UC Berkeley)What We Get Wrong About Teaching Kids to Apologize and Forgive
- Making Caring Common (Harvard Graduate School of Education)How to Help Kids Learn From Mistakes
- Korean Educational Development Institute (한국교육개발원)A study on advancing school culture to strengthen character education (인성교육 강화를 위한 학교문화 선진화 방안 연구)