Rescuing Conversations That End in "I Don't Know" — Practicing Open-Ended Questions

A conversation that starts with "How was school today?" and ends with "I don't know" can keep going if you change the question just a little.

“How was school today?” “I don’t know.” “Was it fun?” “It was okay.” If every evening’s conversation is just these short exchanges, the problem may not be your child’s ability to express themselves but the shape of the question. Questions that can be answered with yes or no make the conversation stop right there.

Why it matters

The Question Formulation Technique (QFT), developed by Dan Rothstein and Luz Santana, founders of the nonprofit education research organization Right Question Institute, holds that the ability to ask good questions is itself a skill that can be learned and practiced. The organization advises that rather than parents handing children answers, the experience of making questions together builds children’s thinking power. Closed questions (“Was it fun?”) end a conversation, while open questions (“What part do you remember most?”) help children draw out their own thoughts.

The Family Dinner Project, run in partnership by Harvard Graduate School of Education’s Project Zero and the Massachusetts General Hospital (MGH) Department of Psychiatry, draws on a range of research showing that a family habit of regular conversation is associated with lower risk of substance abuse and depression in children and with higher academic achievement and self-esteem, and it offers conversation cards for different age groups. The key isn’t big topics but steadily asking “questions that don’t end in yes or no.”

How to make open-ended questions

  • Try putting “why,” “how,” or “what part” at the front of your questions. Just changing “Was it fun?” to “What part was the most fun today?” widens the range of answers.
  • Even if you get “I don’t know,” don’t push; ask again with a slightly more specific question. You don’t have to find the perfect question on the first try.
  • Briefly share your own day first. Children find it easier to open up after hearing their parent’s story.
  • Don’t correct or evaluate answers mid-conversation. The QFT treats holding off on judgment while questions and answers are going back and forth as a core rule.

Try saying:

  • “What was the moment you remember most from today?”
  • “What did you and your friend talk about? What did you say back?”
  • “If you could live today over again, what would you want to do differently?”

FAQ

What if my child still only answers “I don’t know”? Break the question into smaller pieces. Narrowing the scope — “Who did you play with at recess?” instead of “How was school?” — makes it easier for your child to answer.

It’s hard to come up with new questions every time. It’s fine to repeat the same questions. What matters isn’t how original the question is but an attitude of being genuinely curious about your child’s answer all the way through.

Does it have to be at dinnertime? No. Walking to and from school, bath time, before bed — any moment that repeats daily works, even if it’s short. Consistency matters more than a set time of day.

Try this today

  • This evening, change “Was it fun?” to “What part was the most fun?”
  • If you hear “I don’t know,” don’t get upset — ask again with a more specific question
  • Before asking your child, share one sentence about your own day first

Sources

Last reviewed July 17, 2026

  1. Right Question InstituteTeaching Kids at Home with the Question Formulation Technique
  2. The Family Dinner Project (Harvard GSE Project Zero)Conversation Cards
  3. The Family Dinner Project (Harvard GSE Project Zero / MGH Psychiatry Academy)FAQ — The Benefits of Family Dinner
  4. RISS, Korean academic database — dissertation (RISS, 학위논문)Effects of picture-book-based havruta activities on young children's creativity and creative character (그림책 활용의 하브루타 활동이 유아의 창의성 및 창의적 인성에 미치는 영향)