Books They Choose Make Readers — The Start of a Reading Habit
More than the good books parents pick out, the books children choose for themselves are what build a real reading habit.
At a bookstore or library, parents often find themselves nudging their child toward a different book: “This one looks better.” Wanting to choose books that seem educational and high-level is natural, but it can also be the moment that makes a child put down the comic or picture book they were holding. When it comes to raising a child who loves books, who chose the book may matter more than which book it is.
Why it matters
The parent publication of Scholastic, the largest children’s publisher in the US, calls letting children choose their own books the “golden rule” of building a reading habit. Karen Burke, senior vice president of data analytics at Scholastic Education, explains that daily reading builds not only vocabulary and background knowledge but also children’s emotional stability, and Katie Carella, a former teacher and Scholastic editor, says that “the fact that a child chose a book means they want to read it, so every book a child chooses is a good book.” Academic research backs up this instinct. An experimental study by Bains, Spaulding, Ricketts and Krishnan, published in 2026 in the Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology, found that people who chose their own reading material enjoyed it more than when someone else chose for them, and were willing to pay more for that book. The research team explains that the experience of choosing doesn’t just reflect interest; it can also create new interest. An approach like the librarians’ recommended reading list from Korea’s National Library for Children and Young Adults, which first shows a varied set of age-appropriate options and then lets children pick from them, is also a useful reference for putting this principle into practice at home.
Turning self-chosen reading into a habit
- At the library or bookstore, go first to the section your child is drawn to, and notice what kinds of books catch their interest.
- Respect comics, heavily illustrated books and rereading the same series as perfectly good choices.
- Make a small bookshelf or book list of your child’s own, so they can see the books they picked piling up.
- Building a routine of reading, even briefly, at the same time every day (before bed, after breakfast, etc.) makes it easier for the habit to take hold.
Try saying: “Which of these books do you like the most? Let’s start with the one you picked.”
Try saying: “This comic book is good too. The best book is one you enjoy reading.”
Try saying: “How many pages do you want to read today? Reading just as much as you decide is plenty.”
FAQ
My child keeps picking the same book. Shouldn’t I get them to read a wider variety? Rereading the same book is also a natural part of strengthening a reading habit. Once they’re comfortable, just gently widening things, like “Want to look at another book like this one?”, is enough.
I’m worried because they only pick comics or picture books. Even with fewer words, the ability to follow a story and imagine grows just the same. Right now is the time to pile up “books they reach for on their own because they’re fun,” and reading level grows naturally on top of that.
Try this today
- At the library or bookstore, let your child choose one book on their own
- Whatever book your child picks, acknowledge it as “a good choice”
- Create a short daily reading routine at the same time each day, like before bed or after breakfast
Sources
Last reviewed July 17, 2026
- Scholastic ParentsHow to Develop Your Child's Reading Habit
- Bains, Spaulding, Ricketts & Krishnan (Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology, 2026)Providing choice enhances reading motivation
- National Library for Children and Young Adults (국립어린이청소년도서관)Librarians' recommended reading list (사서추천도서 목록)