Debating Pros and Cons from One News Clip — Practice Putting Thoughts into Words

Starting with making questions about one short news story lets your child practice thinking for themselves before picking a side.

When your child watches the news and lets it pass without a thought — or, the opposite, just repeats one side’s opinion word for word — it’s natural to worry a bit. It can feel daunting to know how to build their ability to think and judge for themselves, but you don’t need a formal debate class. A single short news story is enough to start debate practice at home. Upper elementary kids on the edge of adolescence want opinions of their own, but they haven’t yet had much practice organizing those opinions and putting them into words. That’s why guiding them with questions to widen their thinking together, rather than handing them the answer, works especially well.

The Question Formulation Technique (QFT), developed by the nonprofit education research organization Right Question Institute, has six steps in all: designing a question focus, introducing the rules, producing questions, improving questions, prioritizing, and reflecting. Instead of answers, you first make as many questions as possible, then choose which ones to discuss and put them in order of priority. If you show your child one sentence from the news and ask, “What questions come to mind when you read this?” your child practices creating their own things to think about before choosing a side. The Right Question Institute also offers a separate home guide so the technique can be used as-is at home.

Pairing up to trade questions and sharpen ideas is also central to havruta (paired questioning and discussion), a paired-learning pedagogy that comes from the Jewish learning tradition. This approach — asking questions and arguing from different perspectives to sharpen understanding — can be applied directly when a parent and child sit down together to talk about the news. Philosophy for Children (P4C) likewise emphasizes the adult’s role as helping children broaden their own thinking through questions rather than giving answers. A peer-reviewed study published in 2024 in the international journal Frontiers in Psychology reports that students who took part in P4C activities showed significant improvement in speaking skills and reduced presentation anxiety.

Step by step

  1. Set the question focus: Show only the headline or one key sentence from a news story. Don’t share your own opinion first.
  2. Produce questions: Say, “Tell me everything you’re curious about,” and at this stage just write down the questions, with no judging or answering.
  3. Improve the questions: Together, sort the questions into ones that end in yes or no and ones that call for more thinking.
  4. Pick one and debate it: Choose one, and each of you gives one reason for and one reason against.

Try saying: “What are you curious about in this news story? Let’s say all of it. We’ll judge later — for now, let’s just collect questions.”

When your child’s opinion differs from yours, try saying: “We see this differently. Can you tell me more about why you think that?”

When your child says, “I’m not sure,” try saying: “This isn’t about getting the right answer. It’s fine to just say whatever you’re thinking right now.”

FAQ

What kind of news should I choose? Rather than sensational or heated topics, it’s better to start with short stories close to your child’s daily life, like school rules or neighborhood issues.

What if my child keeps insisting on only one side? Rather than arguing back right away, ask questions that get them to imagine another viewpoint: “So what reasons might people on the other side have for thinking that?” If you don’t present your own opinion as the right answer, and honestly say there are parts you haven’t made up your mind about either, your child can comfortably change or keep their view.

Try this today

  • Pick one short news story and make 5 questions about it together
  • Choose one of those questions and each give one reason for and one reason against
  • Explain to your child up front the rule of holding off on judgment and only collecting questions

Sources

Last reviewed July 17, 2026

  1. Right Question InstituteWhat is the QFT?
  2. My Jewish LearningHavruta: Learning in Pairs
  3. Right Question InstituteTeaching Kids at Home with the Question Formulation Technique
  4. Frontiers in PsychologyThe impact of Philosophy for Children (P4C) activities on enhancing the speaking skills of gifted students
  5. Korea Citation Index, KCI (한국학술지인용색인)Effects of lessons applying a havruta-based teaching-learning method (하브루타 기반 교수-학습방법을 적용한 수업의 효과)