Wants and Needs — Conversations That Teach the Value of Things
Rather than flatly refusing when your child asks you to buy something, talking through the difference between wants and needs builds values that last.
“I really need this. Everyone in my class has one!” In the upper elementary years, kids more and more often beg for trendy sneakers, the latest gadgets or character merchandise. If you flatly say no, your child feels their feelings weren’t understood; if you buy everything, they grow up without learning to tell wants from needs. What’s needed at this age isn’t a decision about buying or not buying, but a conversation where you think together about why they want it.
Why it matters
According to research by psychologist Jeffrey Froh, featured by the Greater Good Science Center, a research center affiliated with UC Berkeley’s psychology department, adolescents with stronger materialistic tendencies tended to feel depressed more often and to have lower academic achievement. Dr. Froh describes materialism as “an attitude focused on external goals such as wealth, fame, image and status,” and points out that even when these goals are achieved, the mind’s basic needs aren’t met. A study published in an international journal also reported that interventions that build gratitude actually reduced the belief that “material abundance equals happiness and success.” Making Caring Common, the character-education project at the Harvard Graduate School of Education, likewise names helping children be grateful for what they have and share with others as one of the key principles for raising caring kids. Rather than scolding the wish for things itself, a conversation that looks at that wish together builds healthier values in the long run.
Step by step
1. Sort out “I need it” from “I want it”
When your child begs you to buy something, don’t answer right away; first ask, “Is that something you really need, or something you want?”
2. Plan an experience together instead of a thing
Research has found that people who spent money on experiences rather than things were more satisfied with their relationships. When talk turns to something your child wants, widen the conversation to a family outing or an activity you can do together.
3. Let them choose with their own allowance
Rather than buying everything or refusing everything, let your child set their own priorities within a set allowance.
4. Be open about your own spending standards too
Telling your child what standards you use when you buy things helps them set standards of their own.
Try saying
- “I get that you really want it. But is it because you need it, or because all your friends have one?”
- “Do you want to decide what to buy with this month’s allowance? Just know that once it’s spent, I can’t give you more.”
- “When I buy things, this is what I think about first. What matters to you?”
FAQ
How do I comfort my child when they compare themselves with friends and get upset? After first acknowledging that they’re upset, it helps to talk together about the idea that what they really want may not be the thing itself, but the sense of belonging it stands for.
What if my child gets an allowance but keeps spending it all and asking for more? Rather than scolding right away, repeating a short conversation looking back at what they bought with the money and whether they were happy with it gives your child practice setting their own spending standards.
Try this today
- If your child asks you to buy something today, talk together before buying about whether it’s a “need” or a “want”
- Plan one activity you can do together this weekend instead of buying a thing
Sources
Last reviewed July 17, 2026
- Greater Good Science Center (UC Berkeley)Three Reasons to Raise Grateful Kids
- PMC (National Library of Medicine)Gratitude as an antidote to materialism in young consumers
- Making Caring Common (Harvard Graduate School of Education)7 Tips for Raising Caring Kids
- Financial Supervisory Service (금융감독원)e-Financial Education Center (e-금융교육센터)
- Bank of Korea (한국은행)Economics education for children (online learning) (어린이 경제교육(온라인학습))