When Your Child Lies — Creating an Environment Where Honesty Comes Easier, Before You Scold

Rather than punishing the lie itself, start by creating an environment where your child feels safe telling the truth.

“Mom, I didn’t do it.” When your child flatly denies something even though the evidence is right there, it’s easy to get angry first. But before the fact that they lied, the thing to look at is what this child expects will happen if they tell the truth.

Why it matters

McGill University psychologist Victoria Talwar has studied children’s lying for more than 20 years. Her research explains that the ability to lie itself emerges naturally as part of cognitive development, but whether it hardens into a habit depends on how the adults around the child respond. The harsher and less predictable the punishment, the more a child learns avoidance before honesty. In the end, the key is not “why did you lie?” but how the child feels about whether “it’s safe to tell the truth.” In fact, a 2014 study Talwar took part in found that stories emphasizing punishment for lying, like “Pinocchio” or “The Boy Who Cried Wolf,” did not reduce children’s lying, while the story of “George Washington and the Cherry Tree,” which emphasizes the positive results of honesty, actually increased children’s honest behavior.

Share your feelings before punishment

Another article from the Greater Good Science Center explains that parents expressing their own feelings first, instead of getting angry, helps increase children’s honesty. Instead of scolding “Lying is bad,” try sharing a feeling, like “I felt hurt that you didn’t tell me the truth.” Then your child can predict how you’ll respond, and next time finds the courage to tell the truth.

Creating an environment where honesty comes easier

  • When your child tells the truth, respond first with “Thank you for telling me,” before getting into the consequences.
  • Handle mistakes and lies separately. When you focus on the attempt to hide something rather than the mistake itself, your child has fewer reasons to hide things next time.
  • Let your child often see you honestly admitting your own small, everyday mistakes.
  • When choosing books with your child, pick stories where choosing honesty leads to good results, rather than stories where lying gets punished.
  • Rather than interrogating, give your child time and space to bring things up on their own.

Try saying:

  • “If that’s what happened, you won’t get in trouble if you tell me now. Let’s figure out together what to do.”
  • “I felt hurt that you didn’t tell me the truth. Next time, will you tell me just how it was?”
  • “It’s okay that you made a mistake. But I’m curious why you wanted to hide it.”

FAQ

If my child lies often, is something wrong? Lying at a young age is common as part of imagination and cognitive development. But if it keeps happening out of fear of punishment, it’s worth first taking a look at how you respond.

If I don’t scold them, won’t they keep lying? It’s known that when children build up experiences of being safe when they tell the truth, they actually tell the truth more often. Still deal with responsibility for the wrong behavior together, but move it to after you’ve expressed your feelings.

Should I respond the same way in front of siblings? Yes—in fact, consistent responses matter even more when siblings are watching. If you respond differently to just one child, the children learn “in front of whom it’s okay” before they learn honesty.

Try this today

  • Today, when your child tells the truth, respond with “Thank you for telling me”
  • Before getting angry, first put your own feeling into words, like “I felt hurt”
  • Honestly admit one small mistake of your own in front of your child

Sources

Last reviewed July 17, 2026

  1. Greater Good Science Center (UC Berkeley)Three Steps to Teach Children About Honesty
  2. Greater Good Science Center (UC Berkeley)To Increase Your Child's Honesty, Share Your Feelings
  3. Lee, Talwar, McCarthy, Ross, Evans & Arruda (Psychological Science, 2014)Can Classic Moral Stories Promote Honesty in Children?
  4. Korea Central Childcare Support Center, Ministry of Health and Welfare (중앙육아종합지원센터)Casebook of outstanding character-education programs at daycare centers (인성교육 우수어린이집 프로그램 사례집)