Mediating Sibling Fights — Be an Interpreter, Not a Judge
The more parents act as judges deciding who's right and wrong, the more sibling fights repeat. What kids need is an interpreter who carries each one's feelings to the other.
When siblings start fighting, parents reflexively ask “Who started it?” and try to sort out who’s at fault. But researchers say that the more parents play judge, the more the fights keep coming back. What’s needed isn’t a verdict on who’s right, but an interpreter who carries each child’s feelings to the other.
Why it matters
Child development researcher Laurie Kramer of Northeastern University in the US has studied sibling conflict while running a parent training program called “Fun with Sisters and Brothers” for more than 10 years. According to research published in the journal Family Relations, the children of parents who took part in the program talked about each other’s feelings and suggested their own ways to resolve conflict more often than children whose parents didn’t, and these changes lasted long after the training ended. Kramer explains that when parents act as interpreters who pass each child’s feelings and point of view on to the other, instead of judging who’s right and who’s wrong, children build the ability to find solutions on their own. The University of New Hampshire’s sibling conflict research initiative (SAARA) also advises that when parents stay neutral and don’t take sides, rivalry between siblings actually decreases.
How to be an interpreter instead of a judge
- Ask “How are you feeling right now?” before “Who started it?” Feelings come before fault.
- Pass one child’s words on to the other just as they said them. Something like “Your brother says he’s really upset about this” — simply interpreting for each other is enough.
- Be careful not to take sides. The moment you take a side, the fight can turn into a competition for your attention.
- Don’t decide the solution for them; ask the kids first: “So what do you want to do now?”
Try saying: “How are you feeling right now? Want me to tell your brother exactly that?”
Try saying: “Your brother says he’s upset because of this. What would you like to do?”
Try saying: “Do you two want to try deciding together what to do?”
FAQ
One of my kids keeps saying it isn’t fair. Still shouldn’t I take their side? Do listen fully to the feeling of being treated unfairly. But stopping at acknowledging the feeling, like “I understand how you feel,” rather than judging “who’s right,” is the way to keep the fight from growing.
Do I have to step in every time? At first you’ll often need to step in, but if you keep modeling the interpreter role, children gradually start expressing their feelings and suggesting solutions on their own.
How should I handle siblings with a big age gap differently? Pass on the younger child’s feelings and needs just as seriously as the older one’s. Being younger doesn’t make their feelings any less important.
The solution the kids came up with seems unfair by my standards. It doesn’t have to be a perfect solution right away. If it’s something the kids agreed on between themselves, respecting it, even if it seems a bit lacking to you, builds their ability to solve things on their own.
Try this today
- In the next sibling fight, start with “How are you feeling right now?” instead of “Who started it?”
- Try the interpreter role once by passing one child’s words on to the other just as they said them
- Ask the kids for a solution first, and wait for their answer
Sources
Last reviewed July 17, 2026
- Northeastern UniversityGetting along with siblings can be taught, Northeastern research shows
- Sibling Aggression and Abuse Research and Advocacy Initiative (University of New Hampshire)Recommendations for Parents on Managing Sibling Conflict and Aggression
- Korea Citation Index (KCI, 한국학술지인용색인)A study on types of fathers' verbal responses (아버지의 언어반응 유형에 관한 연구)